In the lead up to our recent “Too Many Carries” podcast episode, I returned the DVD for the 1976 De Palma film to my local video store and decided to pick up another film from the director while I was there, for me to watch as a palate cleanser after enduring two worse versions of the same story. I watched Dressed to Kill earlier this year, and I’d already seen several of the others that weren’t already rented out for the weekend, like The Fury and Body Double. Since I finally got around to seeing Vertigo and not just having absorbed so many images from it via retrospectives that I could recognize its influence in Body Double, I decided to give his other Vertigo knock-off a try. I was not disappointed!
Obsession opens in 1959, where real estate developer Robert LaSalle (John Lithgow) is giving a speech in honor of his business partner Michael Courtland (Cliff Robertson) at the latter’s ten-year anniversary party in Courtland’s Mid-City New Orleans home. That night, Michael’s wife Elizabeth (Geneviève Bujold) and their six-year-old daughter Amy are kidnapped. Despite being instructed not to involve the police, Michael does so, and ends up being convinced by them to deliver a briefcase filled with paper and a radio transmitter in place of the ransom. The police botch their approach to the kidnappers’ location and a car chase ensues, which ends with the car bearing Elizabeth, Amy, and the criminals to a watery grave. A decade and a half later, Michael has kept a large area of valuable real estate as a memorial to his dead wife and daughter, even constructing a symbolic tomb for them that we eventually learn recreates the facade of the San Miniato al Monte basilica in Florence, where Michael and Elizabeth first met. Returning to Florence with Robert for some business meetings, Michael goes to the basilica again, where he sees an art restoration student named Sandra, who is Elizabeth’s doppelganger. Almost immediately, he begins attempting to remake Sandra into Elizabeth in order to have a second chance with her, but there’s more to their apparent chance meeting than meets the eye.
When the podcast crew covered this as part of a discussion of Vertigo rip-offs and homages back in 2021, they seem to unanimously agree that the twists in this one err on the obvious side, but I have to confess that I didn’t see them coming. The revelation of the identity of the villain of the piece may not have been the most shocking, but the actual extent of their long-reaching plans and the depth of their resentment and hatred make for a satisfactory (and stomach-churning) reveal. In particular, there are ways that certain scenes are re-shot with Bujold after the big reveal that are utterly heartbreaking and which Bujold manages to sell despite the potential for silliness in those visualizations of the revisitation of the earlier sequence. The story here is also more compelling than Vertigo’s, since that film largely lacks any recognizable humanity; everyone in that film goes around throwing the word “love” around despite the fact that not a single person (other than Midge) demonstrates love at all. I understand that’s the point in Hitchcock’s film, but here, every motivation is legible, even when they’re inconceivable, whether it be obsession (naturally), greed, or something altogether darker and crueler.
I never once believed that Jimmy Stewart loved Kim Novak (or vice versa), and was flabbergasted when the narrative finally made it explicit that he hadn’t instantly recognized that Judy Barton and Madeleine Elster were one and the same; they are so clearly the same person to anyone with functioning sight that I had assumed he was playing some kind of psychological game with her. Here, I never doubted for a moment that Michael sincerely loved his wife and daughter, and as such, when he sees “Elizabeth” again sixteen years later, I believed that (a) it had been long enough that the resemblance was reasonably coincidental despite the likeness being unusually perfect and (b) that his immediate obsession with Sandra was believable, since he and his wife had a decade of devotion to one another before her death and he seemed genuinely unable to move on with his life. Although several reports indicate that Robertson was deliberately playing his role blandly in order to get back at De Palma for some slight or other, I find his glassy blankness to be perfectly suited to what’s happening, as he seems truly unsure of his reality anymore outside of fixation upon remaking Sandra into Elizabeth’s image.
The list of directors who had been influenced by Hitchcock in general and Vertigo specifically is too long to list, but when I think about who wears that influence on the sleeve most clearly, the three who come to mind are De Palma, Dario Argento, and Park Chan-wook. There’s a weird rhetorical space around Obsession where there’s a confluence of Hitchcock tools and interpretations. For instance, De Palma out-Hitches the man himself in Obsession by bringing in one of the master’s most common recurring elements, the presence of a police force that is useless at best. The police don’t really matter in Vertigo, but they do in Obsession, where their ineptitude is the instigating factor in everything that follows, as their botched job of capturing the criminals is only topped by their utter incompetence at creating a roadblock to prevent them from escaping. The choice to go to Florence for part of the film seems to be an acknowledgement of Hitchcock’s influence on the up-and-coming giallo genre on De Palma’s part, or at least a recognition that he and giallo filmmakers are cutting material from the same cloth. With Park, it’s clear that he drew straightforward inspiration from Shadow of a Doubt for Stoker and Vertigo for Decision to Leave, but there’s also a traceable lineage from Vertigo to Obsession to Old Boy, one that I don’t want to address too directly since it could spoil both of those films, but if you’ve already seen them, then you know what I’m talking about.
The final half-hour of Obsession is pure derangement, and I adored it. The confessional letter that is never completed, Robertson’s bewilderment in the film’s final moments when he grapples with just how much he has been deceived (and for how long), the orbital shots that revolve around our characters as they realize the truth about everything … it’s all great stuff, and pure synthesis of De Palma’s most perverse visions of cinematic beauty and Paul Shrader’s bottomless pit of evil ideas. It might be time for a revisitation of Body Double, but unless or until I do and judge that one to be even better than I remember, this has moved to the top of the tier list of De Palma works for me.
-Mark “Boomer” Redmond













