Victorian Psycho (2026)

When it was first announced that Virginia Feito’s second novel, Victorian Psycho, would be getting an A24-distributed adaptation by Zachary Wigon, Margaret Qualley was attached to star. By the time it made it to theaters, the distributor had changed to Bleecker Street and the film starred Maika Monroe. As to distribution, the average movie-goer probably doesn’t know or care; as to the star, boy, we really lucked out. After Monroe’s very strong double header of The Guest and It Follows in 2014, things have been up and down for her. She was in a sci-fi legasequel that everyone hated, a movie that I not only forgot I reviewed but which I forgot I had even watched, and a contentious Oz Perkins favorite. She stayed working in between all of those, but not necessarily on projects that anyone would care about. Last year’s remake of The Hand that Rocks the Cradle with Monroe in the Rebecca De Mornay role went straight to streaming, and I was deeply saddened on her behalf every time I had to withstand the trailer for the Colleen Hoover adaptation that she was in earlier this year (we’ve all got to pay the bills; I get it). It’s nice to see her getting back on the horse with a winningly unhinged performance in a terrifically oddball feature.

Monroe plays Winnifred Notty (pronounced “naughty”), who arrives at the country estate of Ensor House to serve as the new governess for young Andrew and Drusilla Pounds, bearing her presumed letter of employ, which bears the same house signet as the boar adornments on the building’s exterior. Directed by the house staff to go to the servant entrance in the rear, she is ushered to her room by an unkind housekeeper and instructed to bathe herself before dinner, where she will meet Mr. (Jason Isaacs) and Mrs. (Ruth Wilson) Pounds. The two impress upon her the importance of Andrew’s education—he must be smart, but not too smart, before he heads off to boarding school at the end of the year—as well as their apathy about their daughter Drusilla’s schooling. It is abundantly clear that Drusilla is brighter than her brother, who is destined to inherit everything given that it’s the mid-nineteenth century, and that he has the spoiled demeanor to match. Despite wishing and hoping to herself that things will be different in this house than they were in her previous places of employment, where the children never seemed to make it to adulthood, Winnifred is still barely able to contain her psychotic temperament and ultimately fails to prevent her murderous tendencies from giving her away.

The film calls to mind the Comedy Central series Another Period, which took place in the early 1900s and focused on a pair of nouveau riche sisters trying to break into high society in a faux reality show format (think Downton Abbey meets any number of 2010s Kardashian knockoffs). It’s not as playful with its format, since it doesn’t adopt the talking heads or affluence-showcasing establishing shots that the series did, and instead plays the film as a straight, Brontë sisters-style gothic governess story that just so happens to be about a woman who may or may not be possessed of a spirit called “Fred” that lives inside of her and drives her to kill. The only difference between this and an adaptation of Jane Eyre or The Turn of the Screw is that it’s darkly comedic as well, both in the ironic distance between Winnifred’s diagnosis of herself as “the sanest person [she] ever met” and her compulsive murderousness, but also in the absurd situations in which she finds herself and the extent to which her bizarre behavior is overlooked because her host family is as disaffected as they are wealthy. Early on, Winnifred kills a gardener because he knows her from her killing of a previous ward and attempts to blackmail her, and when she returns to the house bloodied she’s forced to come up with a story about fighting off a ghoul in order to quiet the family’s nurse, Ms. Lamb (Thomasin McKenzie). This ends up becoming a recurring gag but also leads to a real friendship between Winnifred and Lamb that quiets Winnifred’s inner demons for a time, but which comes to a bloody, hilarious end that requires Winnifred replace the Pounds’s baby with a peasant’s infant and sending off a child’s corpse to a nunnery with an apology note that makes it clear this isn’t the first time this has happened to her.

There are many delightfully, darkly comic scenes throughout Victorian Psycho. The boar tapestry in her quarters grows more bizarre and grotesque as Winnifred loses her grip on reality, until it becomes almost Bosch-like. Actual Victorian society takes a few licks as well, with the major social event of the season being the unveiling of a mummy that one of the Pounds’s social circle has openly pilfered from a pyramid using child slaves. The general misogyny of the era means that Drusilla is not given the attention that she deserves but that lack of observation means that no one realizes how clever she is, or how alike she and Winnifred are. The mummy scene culminates with her parents’ discovery of her sketchbook where she’s doodled unflattering caricatures of her parents and their guests that show them sexualizing the mummy. It’s clear that their daughter sees through the subtext of their entire social world and cuts to the core of its colonialism, but they only find it repulsive because of its vulgarity. The film is clever, but not too clever, and it works on multiple levels.

Where things start to fall apart is in the final slasher-esque sequence. Her true motives for having come to Endsor House having come to light, Winnifred has been dismissed from her position, but she sneaks back into the home for Andrew’s birthday party. She finds the entire house welcoming of her and is given a place of honor at the table, but it becomes immediately apparent that this is what she is seeing in her fugue state while she actually murders the entire household. This sequence doesn’t work, partially because it tips its hand that it’s a fantasy sequence too early by having characters move around and disappear as if in a dream, and also because it’s just not as interesting to see Winnifred get what she always wanted in this scene, and externalizing her inner monsters via a “Fred” cloud muddies the entire thing in a way that is not an improvement over excising it altogether, or treating it more mysteriously. Maybe this is something from the novel that it was felt was important to retain in the adaptation, but it doesn’t quite work.

Overall, however, this is a fun one. In this current season of fielding lots of For Your Consideration screeners, I’ve been seeing a host of movies that are aware of (and draw attention to) how Big and Important they are, and the only break from that I took was to watch so much Carrie that I started to feel like they were all laughing at me. It was nice to get out of the house on a rainy day, go down to the megaplex, and eat a hot dog in the darkness while watching Maika Monroe do a Lizzie Borden riff. What’s not to love about that?

-Mark “Boomer” Redmond