Note: This review is of the 88-minute theatrical cut currently available on Criterion Channel, not the restored 108-minute director’s cut that was released by Kino Lorber in 2025.
There are certain movies that no attempt to describe could truly prepare you to see them. Dust Devil, the sophomore feature from Richard Stanley following his debut Hardware, is one of them. The mythology of it all doesn’t really come together into anything all that logical and cohesive, but it has a hazy, discomfiting nightmare quality that gives it a (very effective) Elm Street knock-off feeling combined with a bizarre, Clive Barker-esque deadly eroticism. A sexy, nameless “dust devil” (Robert John Burke) appears on a seemingly endless desert highway and hitches a ride with a woman who takes him back to her place. As they have sex, the man’s own reflection is watching the couple from a mirror. He breaks his partner’s neck, and the next thing we see, he’s painted the inside of her house with sigils and symbols in her blood and fat, taken off with her severed fingers, and set the place ablaze. Sgt. Ben Mukurob (Zakes Mokae), who lives in the drought-stricken, slowly dying former mining town of Bethanie in newly independent Namibia, investigates the crime scene. He recognizes the occult elements of the killing and tries to consult with Joe (John Matshikiza), a folk healer called a Sangoma, but Ben can only conceive of what’s happening as the work of a human serial killer, while Joe tries to convince him to broaden his mind.
On the same night that Ben receives an otherworldly phone call, Wendy Robinson (Chelsea Field) is awakened by her ringing phone across the border in South Africa. After she hangs up on the creepy, nonsensical whispering, her husband Mark takes it as further evidence that she’s having an affair, which he’s suspected for a long time. She leaves him the following day after he hits her while interrogating her, and she decides she’s going to drive straight to the ocean. When she passes through Bethanie after crossing into Namibia, she calls home, leaving a message on the answering machine that Mark will later be able to use to trace her route. Although she draws a bath in a hotel and considers ending her life, she changes her mind at the last second while the dust devil, unseen by her, watches from the inside of her hotel room. The next day, Wendy watches as he hitches a ride with a motorist with a camper and leaves Bethanie behind, but she eventually comes upon him on the road hitchhiking and picks him up, unaware that he’s already added the other driver to his kill list, with the camper itself becoming the next crime scene that Ben investigates.
This movie rocks. I booed when the name “Harvey Weinstein” appeared in the opening credits, and I should have known that any apparent incoherence in the plot of Dust Devil would be because Miramax loved interfering with directorial vision. The mythos of the dust devil doesn’t really make sense. Supposedly, they are former men who somehow exist as spirits but return to the world in the form of humans in order to ritualistically hunt people who have nothing left to live for, but “Texas” (as Wendy nicknames him) also says that he “comes from the other side of the mirror” and that he’s trying to get to the spirit world via all the ritual murder. Contemporary reviews of the film cite its plot as incomprehensible and the overly poetic voiceover from Joe the Sangoma as pretentious, and I can understand that criticism. The Dust Devil that I’ve seen is the compromised cut between Stanley’s initial two-hour version and the Weinstein-spearheaded 90-minute cut that excised all of the supernatural elements and turned the dust devil into a human serial killer with an occult m.o. in an attempt to cash in on the contemporary success of Silence of the Lambs. Of course it’s incoherent; nevertheless, it’s a surprise success in many other ways.
It’s a testament to Stanley that he recognized he was living in a historical moment and jumped at the chance to document and capitalize upon it. Namibia became independent from South Africa in March of 1990, and the ongoing withdrawal of apartheid era white South African occupying forces is a textual part of this story. When Ben is taken to the burned-down house where “Tex” left his first onscreen victim, we meet the apparent chief of police, who essentially hands off the case to Ben; he and his men are basically as checked out as high schoolers during the last week of classes since they’re all going back to South Africa (or maybe even all the way back to Holland) in the next few days. Ben is the inheritor of a peacekeeping system with no infrastructure, which means that he has no backup when things go wrong as he faces off against a truly supernatural entity. The ongoing echo of that conflict carries through to Wendy’s side of the story too. When her husband traces her to Bethanie, he shoves their wedding photo into the faces of patrons at the bar, which doesn’t endear them to him even before they realize that he’s wearing an army uniform in the photo and recognize that he’s a former occupier. The ensuing beating that he gets is quite cathartic.
Dust Devil makes the odd choice to veer into romance territory for a time as well. The general incoherence of the dust devil’s whole deal means that it’s unclear if his declarations that he only takes those who “call to him” because “they have nothing left inside” is an actual binding supernatural code, a self-deception that he’s convinced himself of to justify activities that are functionally those of a serial killer, or an out and out lie. Whatever the case may be, he finds himself unable to go through with killing Wendy, possibly even having fallen in love with her. It ultimately allows for some really fun psychedelic and hallucinatory images. Ultimately, all of the remaining (living) key players converge in the abandoned desert mining town of Kolmanskop, an eerie, real life liminal space, and there’s a spectacular sequence in the town’s theater that showcases the dust devil’s manipulation of reality. From top to bottom, this is a movie that looks fantastic and is full of gorgeous compositions. It’s a shame that it only existed in this incomplete, studio-mandated form for decades, but even in this cut, it’s still an excellent movie. It doesn’t cohere, but it makes enough sense, and it’s a rewarding ride.
-Mark “Boomer” Redmond

