I recently saw a trailer for Greta Gerwig’s upcoming adaptation of the Narnia franchise-starter The Magician’s Nephew at my local AMC, packaged alongside a nonstop parade of ads for other kid-friendly movies before a screening of Wildwood. The trailer climaxes with the literal creation of the universe, with the divine lion Aslan exploding into a Big Bang constellation of lights that regather to represent everything we know & love in life. It is the image of a god performing the ultimate miracle, and it somehow could not feel more mundane. I’ve been feeling that feeling a lot lately. The big-budget spectacle of galactic-scale divine beings altering our physical world through the magical conduit of CGI just isn’t inspiring much awe. The year’s most astonishing works have been, in my eyes, much more intimate in their scope: the TV-movie melodrama of Maddie’s Secret, the furry familial woes of Bouchra, the restaurant-chain competition of Buffet Infinity, the Olympic-training crises of Agon, etc. Meanwhile, Christopher Nolan’s poetic epic The Odyssey has been preemptively crowned as the de facto Movie of the Year by most movie-culture pundits, with only Denis Villeneuve’s upcoming Dune sequel threatening to take its spot. I enjoyed watching The Odyssey. Nolan at least found a way to make human confrontations with the divine feel tactile & halfway real as Odysseus hopped islands from monster to witch to god to god. Despite all of its supernatural CG majesty, The Odyssey has a grounded sense of physicality that’s missing from Gerwig’s galactic image of Aslan creating the universe, whereas you’d expect the mumblecore veteran to be more interested in small-scale humanity than the current reigning king of movie-studio spectacle. It’s not really her fault, nor is it fair for me to judge a movie by its trailer. It’s just that using the great Hollywood dream machine to convene with the gods usually has the same emotional impact as a Windows screensaver. Even Nolan’s more stripped-down, grounded version didn’t leave much of a lasting impression beyond its appeal as an afternoon’s indoor entertainment.
The computer-generated god I most often convene with at the movies is, of course, Godzilla. The walking, roaring atomic-warfare metaphor is synonymous with cinematic spectacle in the Japanese tokusatsu subgenre, and his onscreen presence is supposed to inspire otherworldly awe every time he appears onscreen. The same goes for his most evil nemesis, the three-headed space dragon Ghidorah, who appears again in full CG splendor to fight Godzilla in the new film Godzilla Minus Zero. The resulting battle of the gods is extremely loud and incredibly morose. Godzilla Minus Zero pulls a lot of the same dramatic tricks as Godzilla Minus One, but they still work for the most part. The humans cowering under Godzilla’s gigantic feet have a lot more going on dramatically than their counterparts in Godzilla movies past, with director (and special effects supervisor) Takashi Yamazaki making it clear just how much that unfathomable lizard-god’s destruction mirrors their exact experience in the atomic bombing of Hiroshima, through direct juxtaposition. If Godzilla Minus Zero does anything especially new or useful within the greater Godzilla canon, it’s in the way it makes it clear just how terrified Godzilla’s victims are by his sudden return, not to mention the newly discovered threat of his three-headed peer. It’s a portrait of a community in hurt, one that barely has the strength to devise a plan to get the two monster-gods to fight each other in an act of mutual destruction. Once that fight starts, though, the human drama takes a back seat to large-scale CG spectacle, charting the blow-by-blow fight to the death between Godzilla & Ghidorah in the rubble of a previously flattened Japanese city. As far as climactic monster battles go, it’s an especially metal one, as it was so loud in its vicious mayhem that it blew out one of the speakers in the theater where I watched it. I just found the emotions of the moment a little dull when compared to the communal dread leading up to that terrifically divine event.
I also heard a blown-out speaker rattling in my screening of Ramayana, Part 1: The Rise of a Legend at a different theater chain on the opposite side of town. That half-adaptation of the traditional Hindu epic has been reported to be the biggest-budget production in the history of Indian cinema. It’s more spectacular than The Odyssey, with its own onscreen gods depicted with the same galactic abstraction as Aslan in the Narnia trailer. It’s more violent than Godzilla Minus Zero, with a higher battlefield bodycount and its own vicious blow-by-blow fight that leaves the talking-bird demigod Jatayu brutally beaten & de-winged in its climactic fight. It’s also not nearly as dramatically compelling as either of those counterpoints but, oh well, you can’t win ’em all. Part 1 of this epic journey follows Ram, a human avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu, as he is gradually drawn into a good-vs-evil battle with the demonic king Ravana, who starts a war by kidnapping Ram’s wife Sita (herself an avatar of the Hindu goddess Lakshmi). The religious & cultural details of these cosmic-scale players may not be familiar to most Western audiences, but the CG spectacle of their battlefield victories certainly will be. The project of this latest Ramayana adaptation appears to be updating the material to match the aesthetic sensibilities of modern blockbuster filmmaking, marrying the traditions of old with the entertainments of now. Its positioning as the Bollywood equivalent of The Odyssey could not have been better timed, and is unmistakable once Ram has to prove his devotion to Sita by stringing a bow in a crowd of outmatched competitors, the same as Odysseus & Penelope. It’s much less interested in turning its symbolic figures into real, recognizably human characters the way Nolan’s film does, though, as it’s more interested in chasing a post-MCU superhero sensibility that leaves them feeling just as abstractly rendered as ever. All you can really do is marvel at their physical feats without ever truly getting to know them as people.
In general, it feels like most of these grand attempts to represent divine beings onscreen is a response to the void left by superhero cinema. Just a few years ago, adaptations of Marvel & DC Comics dominated the cultural conversation around movies on a week-to-week basis, but audiences seemingly got numb to those CG spectacles and moved on. Movie studios have been scrambling ever since to come up with the Next Big Thing that will inspire awe in the audiences that abandoned their superhero gods with no urgency to find new ones as replacement. Epic-scale adaptations of culturally established myths like The Odyssey, The Ramayana, and, yes, Godzilla, are filling the void left by superheroes, to mostly positive results. These are all good-to-great movies and, with any luck, Greta Gerwig’s Narnia trilogy will be too. It’s just a little disappointing that their grand-scale productions and their daringness to convene with the divine suggest a transcendent, awe-inspiring experience that major studio filmmaking can rarely deliver. When anything is possible, including direct interaction with literal gods, nothing is especially impressive. As always, the most exciting movies being made right now are dirt-cheap form-breakers pushing with all their might against the restraints of their budgets. At the movies, as in life, the truly divine can only be found in the ordinary, as it only gets more abstract & intangible as you zoom out to the bigger picture.
-Brandon Ledet
